Search

Search investigations, people, organizations, evidence and topics

A white humanoid collaborative robot beside the engineer who trains its perception
Nicholas-halodi · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

ProvocationseedpublicÆrthRobotics

Could humanoid robots become economically viable for hospital logistics in Brazil?

A provocation on whether humanoid robots can beat human labor cost in Brazilian hospital logistics before 2030.

2
claims
1
evidence in favour
2
counterarguments
2
derivations
What is missing here
  • 1 question without an answer
  • 1 claim without evidence

Meaningful events on this object. Security audit entries are kept separately and are visible to administrators only.

  1. DL
    Dr. Lucas Almeida attached evidence to
    e2e-mech-paper (supports)
    1 month ago
  2. DL
    Dr. Lucas Almeida attached evidence to
    e2e-mech-paper (supports)
    1 month ago
  3. DL
    Dr. Lucas Almeida attached evidence to
    e2e-mech-paper (supports)
    1 month ago
  4. PM
    Prof. Marina Costa attached evidence to
    Humanoid robot BOM cost analysis 2025 (fictional) (contextualizes)
    2 months ago
  5. PM
    Prof. Marina Costa contributed to
    Intervention in scrutiny: request evidence
    2 months ago
  6. DW
    Dr. Wei Zhang contributed to
    Intervention in scrutiny: attack premise
    2 months ago
  7. AF
    Ana Ferreira opened a scrutiny or review of
    What would make humanoid logistics uneconomic even at USD 20k a unit?
    2 months ago
  8. JP
    João Pereira derived new work from
    Uptime guarantees as a condition for hospital robot procurement
    2 months ago
  9. JP
    João Pereira attached evidence to
    Hospital robot fleet uptime survey 2025 (fictional) (supports)
    2 months ago
  10. JP
    João Pereira added a claim on
    Fleet uptime below 90% makes humanoid logistics uneconomic regardless of unit price.
    2 months ago
  11. JP
    João Pereira changed a claim status on
    Claim now supported: Humanoid unit cost will fall below USD 30,000 by 2029, making a 3-year TCO competitive with one full
    2 months ago
  12. JP
    João Pereira contributed to
    Uptime is the real constraint: a 24/7 hospital cannot tolerate a fleet that is down 15% of the time.
    2 months ago
  13. DL
    Dr. Lucas Almeida derived new work from
    Total cost of ownership of humanoid logistics in Brazilian private hospitals falls below human labor cost by 2029
    2 months ago
  14. PM
    Prof. Marina Costa recorded an assumption on
    Existing hospital corridors and elevators can be used by humanoids without retrofit.
    2 months ago
  15. PM
    Prof. Marina Costa contributed to
    We assume hospital corridors and elevators can be used without retrofit.
    2 months ago
  16. DW
    Dr. Wei Zhang contributed to
    Cost per unit is the wrong metric. Availability in a 24/7 hospital is what kills the business case.
    2 months ago
  17. RD
    Rafael Duarte contributed to
    Has anyone modelled the maintenance network cost outside São Paulo and Rio?
    2 months ago
  18. CN
    Camila Nakamura attached evidence to
    ANVISA RDC on medical device risk classes (fictional summary) (contextualizes)
    2 months ago
  19. RD
    Rafael Duarte attached evidence to
    Humanoid robot BOM cost analysis 2025 (fictional) (supports)
    2 months ago
  20. DW
    Dr. Wei Zhang changed a claim status on
    Claim now disputed: Humanoid unit cost will fall below USD 30,000 by 2029, making a 3-year TCO competitive with one full
    2 months ago
  21. PM
    Prof. Marina Costa added a claim on
    Humanoid unit cost will fall below USD 30,000 by 2029, making a 3-year TCO competitive with one full-time logistics worker in São Paulo.
    2 months ago
  22. AF
    Ana Ferreira opened
    2 months ago